Swing and a Miss: Apple TV+’s ‘Stick’ Struggles to Match ‘Ted Lasso’ Magic
Apple TV+ has rolled out another comedy series, ‘Stick,’ hoping to capture the heartfelt charm of its predecessor, ‘Ted Lasso.’ Starring Owen Wilson and Marc Maron, this new show dives into the world of sports with a focus on underdog stories and personal redemption. Wilson plays a washed-up baseball coach with a knack for quirky optimism, while Maron portrays his gruff, disillusioned assistant. Together, they attempt to turn around a struggling minor league team, navigating personal demons and locker room drama with a mix of humor and melancholy.
At its core, ‘Stick’ aims to explore the emotional lives of men who feel stuck—whether in their careers, relationships, or self-worth. The series leans heavily on its lead actors’ natural charisma, with Wilson delivering his signature laid-back warmth and Maron bringing a sharp, sardonic edge. Their dynamic offers some genuine laughs, especially in moments of banter over stale coffee and faded dreams. Yet, despite these strengths, the show often feels like it’s swinging for the fences but landing a foul ball. The writing, while earnest, lacks the sharp wit and emotional depth that made ‘Ted Lasso’ a cultural phenomenon. Instead, ‘Stick’ occasionally stumbles into predictable tropes about sad men finding purpose through sports.
Visually, the series captures the gritty charm of small-town ballparks, with dusty fields and flickering scoreboard lights setting a nostalgic tone. The supporting cast, including a roster of young players with their own quirks, adds some color to the narrative. However, the pacing can feel uneven, with episodes dragging through repetitive conflicts or rushed resolutions. Where ‘Ted Lasso’ balanced humor with poignant life lessons, ‘Stick’ sometimes feels weighed down by its own melancholy, leaving viewers longing for more uplifting payoffs.
One of the show’s more intriguing elements is its exploration of mentorship and legacy. Wilson’s character grapples with the fear of being forgotten, while Maron’s bitter outlook challenges the idea of second chances. These themes resonate in a world where many feel overlooked or past their prime, but the execution often feels heavy-handed, lacking the subtlety needed to truly hit home. Fans of character-driven comedies will find moments to appreciate, particularly in quieter scenes of vulnerability, but the overall impact feels muted compared to Apple TV+’s heavier hitters.
As ‘Stick’ rounds out its first season, it’s clear the show has heart and potential. With a talented cast and a relatable premise, there’s room to grow if the writers can find a fresher angle on the ‘sad dudes in sports’ narrative. For now, it remains a watchable but underwhelming addition to the streaming lineup, a reminder that not every swing results in a home run. Viewers looking for a lighthearted escape might enjoy the ride, but those expecting another ‘Ted Lasso’ may leave the ballpark a bit disappointed.